Introducción al modelo de cumplimiento tributario cooperativoestudio de los trabajos de la OCDE y principales experiencias internacionales

  1. Calderón Carrero, José Manuel
  2. Quintas Seara, Alberto
Journal:
Civitas. Revista española de derecho financiero

ISSN: 0210-8453 2695-7493

Year of publication: 2015

Issue: 167

Pages: 75-134

Type: Article

More publications in: Civitas. Revista española de derecho financiero

Bibliographic References

  • “Informe Varney” elaborado por la Administración tributaria del Reino Unido (HMRC, 2006 Review of Links with Large Business, HMRC, 2006, www-hmrc.gov.uk/large-business/review-report.pdf).
  • ATO, Building Confidence, 3 March 2015.
  • ATO, Cooperative Compliance Working with large business in the new tax system, Canberra, 2000
  • ATO, Re:think. Tax Discussion Paper, March 2015, Capítulos 10 y 11.
  • ATO, Risks to the sustainability of Australia’s Corporate Tax Base (Scoping Paper), July 2013, p.55.
  • AUSTRALIAN TAXATION OFFICE (ATO), AUSTRALIAN TAXATION OFFICE (ATO), Large Business and tax compliance, Canberra, 2014.
  • BRAITHWHITE, V., “Responsive regulation and taxation: Introduction”, Law & Policy, vol. 29, nº 1, 2007, pp. 3 y ss.).
  • BRAUNER, Y., “BEPS: An interim Evaluation”, World Tax Journal, vol.6, nº1, 2014, pp.35 y ss.
  • BRONZEWSKA, K., VAN DER ENDEN, E., “Tax control framework. A conceptual approach: the six nuances of good tax governance”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.68, nº11, pp.635-636.
  • BROWN, K. et al, “’Tis the season to obtain certainty”, PWC IRS Hot Topics, 14 October 2013, p.1.
  • BROZEWSKA, K., VAN DER ENDEN, E., “Tax control framework. A conceptual approach: the six nuances of good tax governance”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.68, nº11, pp.635 y ss.
  • CALDERÓN CARRERO, J.M., “La Estrategia Europea de lucha contra el fraude y la Evasión fiscal”, Revista de Contabilidad y Tributación, nº 363, 2013.
  • CALDERÓN CARRERO, J.M., El derecho de los Contribuyentes al Secreto Tributario, Net Biblo, A Coruña, 2009.
  • CALDERÓN CARRERO, J.M., QUINTAS SEARA, A., Cumplimiento tributario cooperativo y buena gobernanza fiscal en la era BEPS, Thomson Reuters-Civitas, Cizur Menor (Navarra), 2015.
  • CALDERÓN, J.M., “La modernización BEPS del marco de principios sobre prácticas fiscales perniciosas: las nuevas exigencias de transparencia (rulings/APAs) y de actividad sustancial aplicadas a IP regimes”, Avance Fiscal Ciss, Noviembre 2014, pp.5-11).
  • CALDERÓN, J.M., Advanced Price Agreements, Kluwer, London, 1998.
  • CASIMIR, J.P., “L’évolution du rescrit fiscal en France”, en AA.VV., Liber Amicorum Jacques Malherbe, Bruyllant, Bruxelles, 2006, pp.209-222).
  • CCBE, CCBE Response to OECD Working Papers on the Role of Tax intermediaries, Brussels, 2007.
  • CLARKE, P., et alter, “Cooperative Compliance: the new frontier for global mobility programs”, PWC Tax Policy Bulletin, October 30, 2014.
  • COLEMAN, C., Mc KERCHAR, M., “The Chicken or the Egg?: A Historical Review of the Influence of Tax Administration on the Development of Income Tax Law in Australia”, en TILEY, J. (ed.), Studies in the History of Tax Law, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 2004, pp.310-312
  • Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) a efectos de buen gobierno corporativo ( COSO, Integrated Framework, disponible en www.coso.org/resources.htm)
  • CORREIA, F., REIBEL, R., “Change of climate in taxation: are you prepared for extended responsibilities?”, European Taxation, vol.54, nº6, 2014, p.270.
  • COUZIN, R., DOMMES, S., DUNAHOO, C., LAMBOOI, M., NIKIEL, W., SCHWARZ, J., TRON, M., IFA Initiative on the Enhanced Relationship, Version 2.3, IFA, 2012.
  • Cuarta Reunión del FAT celebrada en el año 2008 en Ciudad del Cabo, importantes documentos de trabajo entre los que destaca el titulado “Study into the Role of Tax Intermediaries”.
  • D’ASCENZO, M., “Modernising the Australian Taxation Office: Vision, people, systems and values”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.13, nº 1, 2015, pp.361 y ss.
  • DELOITTE, European Tax Survey 2014. Rising to the challenge, pp.2 y ss.).
  • DIRKIS, M., “Observations on the development of Australia’s Income Tax Policy and Income Tax Law”, Bulletin for International Fiscal Documentation, vol.56, nº10, 2002, p.522 y ss.).
  • EBERHARTINGER, E., LEE, S., “The relevance of tax information in other comprehensive income”, WU International Taxation Research Papers Series, nº 7, 2014).
  • El Informe de la OECD, Co-operative Compliance: A Framework from Enhanced relationship to co-operative compliance, Paris, 2013, p.42 c
  • FREEDMAN, J. et al, “Corportate Tax Risk and Tax Avoidance: New Approaches”, British Tax Review, nº 1, 2009, pp.76 y ss.
  • FREEDMAN, J., “Responsive Regulation, Risk and Rules: Applying the Theory to Tax Practice”, UBC Law, vol.44, 2011, pp.649-650.
  • GANGL, K., et alter, “How can I help you? Perceived service orientation of tax authorities and tax compliance”, WU International Taxation Research Paper Series, nº2013-02
  • GARRIGUES, “El código de buenas prácticas tributarias”, Novedades Fiscal, 1-2010, julio de 2010, p. 1, accesible a través del siguiente enlace: http://www.garrigues.com/es/Publicaciones/Novedades/Documents/Novedades_Fiscal_1_2010_30072010134314.pdf
  • GASCÓN CATALÁN, J., “Estrategias fiscales y marcos de control interno y de gestión de riesgos fiscales en las sociedades cotizadas. Impacto de la Ley 31/2014”, Crónica Tributaria, nº 155, 2015, pp.87 y ss.
  • GASCÓN CATALÁN, J., “Los Consejos de Administración como máximos responsables de la estrategia fiscal de las sociedades cotizadas”, Documentos del IEF, nº 19/2014, pp.7-29
  • HAPPÉ, R., “Multinationals, Enforcement Convenants and Fair Share”, Intertax, vol.35, nº10, 2007, pp.537-547.
  • HARVEY, J.R., “FATCA and Schedule UTP: are these unilateral US actions doomed unless adopted by other countries?”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.10, nº2, 2012, pp.304 y ss.).
  • HEL-VAN DIJK, E.C.J.M. van der, “The European Union and More Effective Tax Audits”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.65, nº3, 2011, pp.163-164
  • HEL-VAN DIJK, E.C.J.M. van der, POOLEN, T., “Horizontal Monitoring in The Netherlands: at the crossroads”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.67, nº 12, 2013, pp.673 y ss.
  • HEL-VAN DIJK, L. van der, PHEIJFFER, M., “A tailor-made approach to fiscal supervision: an evaluation of horizontal monitoring”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.66, nº 10, 2012, pp.578-581.
  • HMRC, Making a difference: clarity and certainty, October 2007.
  • HMRC, Research to Support the Implementation of proposals in the Review of Links with Large Business, Research Report, nº58, 2007, p.27.
  • HMRC, Tax in the BoardRoom, p.2 (disponible en www.hmrc.gov.uk/lbo/tax-in-the-boardroom.htm).
  • HOFMANN, E., et alter, “Enhancing tax compliance through coercive and legitimate power of authorities”, WU International Taxation Research Paper Series, nº2013-01
  • HOYNG, R., KLOOSTERHOF, S., MACPHERSON, A., “Tax Control Framework”, en BAKKER, A., KLOOSTERHOF, S. (ed.) Tax Risk Management. From Risk to Opportunity, IBFD, Amsterdam, 2010, pp.21-71
  • Informe de la House of Lords del Reino Unido, Tackling corporate tax avoidance in a global economy: is a new approach needed?, publicado el 31 de julio de 2013,
  • Informe OECD, Co-operative Compliance: A Framework from Enhanced relationship to co-operative compliance, Paris, 2013.
  • JENSEN, J., WÖHLBIER, F., “Improving Governance in the EU Member States: Criteria for successful policies”, European Economy. Occasional papers, nº114, European Commission, Brussels, 2012.
  • KIRCHLER, E., HOELZL, E., “Modelling taxpayer´s behaviour as a function of interaction between tax authorities and taxpayers” en EFFERS, H., HUISMANN, W., VERBOON, P., Managing and maintaining compliance, Boom Legal Publishers, The Hague, 2006, para.3.1
  • KPMG, “Chile- Transfer Pricing Provisions passed under recent tax reform”, TaxNewsFlash, nº60, Septiembre 2012).
  • KPMG, “SAT’s issuance Announcement on taxpayer self-adjustments approach within China’s monitoring and administration system”, China tax alert, Issue 2, September 2014.
  • LANGHAM, J., PAULSEN, N., “Effective engagement: Building a relationship of cooperation and trust within the community”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.13, nº 1, 2015, pp.378 y ss.
  • LAVERMICOCCA, C. “Tax Risk Management Practices and their Impact on Tax Compliance Behaviour – The Views of Tax Executives from Large Australian Companies”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.9, nº1, 2011, pp.94 y ss. Por otra parte, aunque arrojando las mismas conclusiones
  • LAVERMICOCCA, C., BUCHAN, J., “Role of reputational risk in tax decision making by large companies”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.13, nº1, 2015 pp.5-50).
  • MARTÍN FERNÁNDEZ, J., “El Código de buenas prácticas tributarias”, publicado en Cinco Días, 24 de enero de 2011
  • MARTÍN JIMÉNEZ, A., CALDERÓN CARRERO, J.M., “El Plan de Acción de la OCDE para eliminar la erosión de bases imponibles y el traslado de beneficios a otras jurisdicciones (BEPS): ¿El final, el principio del final o el final del principio?, Quincena Fiscal, nº1-2, 2014, pp.87 y ss.
  • MATTHEWS, S., “What is a “competitive” tax system?”, OECD Taxation Working Papers, No.2, OECD, Paris, 2011, pp.5 y ss.
  • MCKERCHAR, M., BLOOMQUIST, K., POPE, J., “Indicators of tax morale: an explanatory study”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol.11, nº1, 2013, pp.18-19.
  • MURPHY, K., “Moving forward towards a more effective model of regulatory enforcement in the Australian Taxation Office”, British tax review, vol. 6, 2004, pp. 603-619.
  • NOLAN, D., FRANK, N., “Tax Dispute Resolution: a new Chapter Emerges”, Tax Notes International, vol.62, nº9, 2011, pp.733-743.
  • NTCA, Horizontal Monitoring Guide: within the medium to very large business segment, The Hague, november 2010, accesible en http://www.indirecttaxfunctioneffectiveness.com/files/44482610.pdf
  • OECD, BEPS Action 14: Make Dispute Resolution Mechanism more Effective, December 16 2014
  • OECD, Study into the Role of Tax Intermediaries, Paris, 2008, pp.10-11.
  • OECD, Compliance Risk Management: Managing and Improving Tax Compliance (Guidance Note), Paris, 2004, p.4. Este documento se encuentra accesible a través del enlace http://www.oecd.org/site/ctpfta/37212610.pdf.
  • OECD, Co-operative Compliance: A Framework from Enhanced relationship to co-operative compliance, Paris, 2013.
  • OECD, General Administrative Principles: Corporate governance and tax risk management. Information Note, Paris, 2009, p.16.
  • OECD, Programs to reduce the administrative burden of tax regulations (follow-up report), Paris, 2010, p.9.
  • OECD, Right from the Start: Influencing the Compliance Environment for Small and Medium Enterprises, Paris, 2012
  • OECD, Study into the Role of Tax Intermediaries, Paris, 2008.
  • OECD, Tax Compliance by Design. Achieving improved SME Tax Compliance by Adopting a System perspective, OECD, Paris, 2014).
  • OECD, Tax Intermediaries Study. Working Paper 6, “The Enhanced Relationship”, 2007, p.11.
  • OECD, Tax Intermediaries Study. Working Paper 6, “The Enhanced Relationship”, 2007.
  • OWENS, J., “Trends and Challenges in the Tax Arena”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol. 66, nº 12, 2012, pp.685 y ss.
  • PAHLSSON, R., “Enhanced Relationship Challenging the Swedish Model”, Intertax, vol.41, nº4, 2013, pp.252 y ss.,
  • PARILLO, K., “UK, Canada Highlight Collaborative Efforts”, Tax Notes International, 28 February 2011, p.648).
  • PETOLICK, G., “United States”, en BAKKER, A., KLOOSTERHOF, S. (ed.) Tax Risk Management. From Risk to Opportunity, IBFD, Amsterdam, 2010, pp.459-460.
  • PWC, “French government announces measures to increase transparency and promote trust between the French tax authorities and taxpayers during tax audits”, Tax Insights from Tax Controversy and Dispute Resolution, April 30, 2015, p.2.
  • QUIGLEY, E., “Irish Transfer Pricing Compliance Reviews”, KPMG Tax Update, Ireland, November 2012.
  • REIBEL, R., “A Developing Relationship: Tax Authority-Taxpayer-Tax Adviser”, European Taxation, vol.51, nº 2-3, 2011, p.100
  • REINHARDT, P. et alte r, “Russian State Duma adopts draft tax monitoring law”, Global Tax Alert EY, 29 October 2014.
  • ROMANÍ SANCHO, A., “La nueva relación Hacienda-contribuyente auspiciada por la OCDE: la relación cooperativa. El Foro de Grandes Empresas y el Código de Buenas Prácticas Tributarias”, Cuadernos de Formación IEF, colaboración 41/10, Volumen 11, 2010, p. 276.
  • RONZEWSKA, K., VAN DER ENDEN, E., “Tax control framework. A conceptual approach: the six nuances of good tax governance”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol.68, nº11, pp.635 y ss.
  • ROSSIGNOL J.L., “Taxation: A New Corporate governance Instrument in France?”, Intertax, vol.38, nº 8-9, 2010, p.462.
  • RUIBAL PEREIRA, L., “Experiencia internacional sobre medidas de reorganización de las administraciones tributarias en la lucha contra el fraude fiscal", Documentos del IEF, nº 27, 2008, p. 5.
  • SAFARYAN, G., SMOUROVA, J., “New rules of the game in taxpayers’ relations with the Russian tax authorities”, CMS tax alert, 19 June 2014, y REINHARDT, P., RODIONOV, I., GURYEV, R., “Plans for new cooperative compliance program for large taxpayers in Russia”, Global tax alert, EY 10 July 2014
  • SANDELL, J., “The Double Irish and the Dutch Sandwich: How Some US Companies are Flummoxing the Tax Code”, Tax Notes International, vol. 67, nº 9, 2012, pp. 867 y ss.
  • SANGER, C., “The Outlook for Global Tax Policy in 2013”, TNI, vol.70, nº10, 2013, pp.979 y ss.
  • SANZ GOMEZ, R., “Hacia la relación cooperativa en España: el nuevo Código de Buenas Prácticas Fiscales a la luz de los estudios de la OCDE”, Revista Técnica Tributaria, abril-junio 2011, pp.76 y ss.
  • SEER, R., “Voluntary Compliance”, Bulletin for International Taxation, vol. 67, nº 11, 2013, pp.585-589).
  • SEER, R., Tax shelter Disclosure and Civil Penalties Rules, 2006, accesible a través del enlace http://www.itdweb.org/documents/ITD_seer.pdf.
  • SOLER ROCH, M.T., “Forum: Tax Administration versus Taxpayer—A New Deal?”, World Tax Journal, vol.4, nº 3, 2012, pp.293-294.
  • SVENSSON, D., “International Tax Audits and Disputes—The Second Wave is on the Horizon”, TNI, vol.70, nº10, 2013, pp.989 y ss.
  • TRIVEDI, S., “More Business-Government Dialogue on Tax Reform Urged”, Tax Notes International, 15 October 2012, pp.274-275).
  • US General Accountancy Office, Corporate Tax Compliance, August 2013.
  • US Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, Highlights, Final Report, Issued on February 2013.
  • VALENTE, P., “Cabinet Approves Draft Tax Reform Bill”, Tax Notes International, vol.66, nº 4, 2012, pp.334 y ss.
  • Valente, P., Vicenti, F., “Italy´s measures against tax evasion and aggressive tax planning”, TNI, vol. 69, nº 11, 2013, pp.1043 y ss.
  • VAN CASTEREN, M., “Horizontal Monitoring in The Netherlands”, en CHESSMAN, S. et al., “Governments and Information Gathering: Impact on MNE Planning”, Tax Management International Journal, vol. 39, nº 12, 2010, pp. 17 y ss.
  • VAN DER ENDEN, E., BRONZEWSKA, K., “The concept of cooperative compliance”, BIT, vol.68, nº10, 2014, pp.567 y ss.
  • VAN HERKSEN, M., “Can International Tax Dispute Resolution be Resuscitated? An analysis of comments to the OECD BEPS Action 14”, Transfer Pricing Report 2015 .
  • VOLLEBREGT, H., “From Red Tape to Red Carpet: How the Netherlands Has changed the traditional dispute landscape for tax issues”, ITPJ, May/June 2009, pp.161 y ss.).
  • WHAIT, R., “Let’s talk about tax compliance: Building understanding and relationships through discourse”, eJournal of Tax Research, vol. 13, nº 1, 2015, pp. 130-157.